• The ARTFL Project
  • PhiloLogic4
  • University of Chicago
  • ASECS

ARTFL Encyclopédie - Robert Morrissey, General Editor; Glenn Roe, Assoc. Editor

  • Search
  • Plate Image Search
  • Front Matter
  • Introduction
  • Encyclopédistes
Home » Editor's Introduction » Encyclopédie Corrections

Table of Contents

  • Research & Archival Materials
  • The "18th" Volume
  • Sequence Alignment
  • Citing the Encyclopédie
  • Encyclopédie Collaborations
  • Encyclopédie Méthodique
  • Supplément de Panckoucke
  • Working Papers
  • Front Matter
  • Editor's Introduction
    • Version Française
    • Encyclopédie Corrections
      • Text Corrections
      • Metadata Corrections
      • Greek Corrections
    • Facts and Numbers
  • The Encyclopédistes
  • Development Team
  • Contact Us

ARTFL Links

  • The ARTFL Project
  • PhiloLogic4
  • University of Chicago
  • ASECS

Metadata Corrections

    Three major types of metadata corrections at the article level:
      1. Article Classifications (class of knowledge, Nom de science)
      2. Article Authors
      3. Article Headwords (main and sub articles)

    Classes of Knowedge

      Thanks to work by a team of students led by Dena Goodman at the University of Michigan we have both "normalized" (orthographically) and english translations of the original classes of knowledge.

      Examples:
        Original class - Geog. ; Geogr. ; terme de Geographie
        Normalized class - Géographie
        English class - Geography

      For questions about "Normalized" classes and the translations. (e.g., "terme d'Ecole; Terme d'école; School term"), please Contact Us.

    Problems with Authorship

      Correction Statement - 1st Edition (1998): 
      Please note that we have not yet attempted to integrate the results of numerous studies of the authors of articles found in the Encyclopédie or authorial attributions not found in the Encyclopédie itself. The most important of these studies include:

      Richard N. Schwab, Walter E. Rex and John Lough, Inventory of Diderot's Encyclopédie in Studies on Voltaire and the Eighteenth Century (volumes 80, 83, 85, 91, 92, 93, 223; 1971-1984); 
      Frank Kafker, The Encyclopedists as Individuals in SVEC, vol. 257, 1988, and 
      1. "Liste des articles de l'Encyclopédie portant l'astérisque" (pp. 133 - 206) 2. "Liste des articles non signés qu'on peut attribuer avec certitude à Diderot et qui sont reproduits dans cette édition" (pp. 207 - 210) 3. "Liste des articles non signés qu'on pourrait peut-être attribuer à Diderot, mais qui ne sont pas reproduits dans cette édition" (pp. 211-219) in John Lough and Jacques Proust, Oeuvres Complètes de Diderot, Edition critique et annotée, volume 5 (Paris, Hermann, 1976).
      We strongly recommend that our users consult these works to verify results concerning attribution and authorship obtained from our site.

       

      Using the Schwab Inventory
      Richard N. Schwab, Walter E. Rex and John Lough, Inventory of Diderot's Encyclopédie (1971-1984)
      • Meetings in Chicago and Paris with Pierre Caye, Martine Groult, Serge Trottein (CNRS - Centre Jean Pépin) - Fall 2007
      • Built a corrections database for searching Schwab in order to incorporate remote corrections
      • First experiment: 1,600 unsigned articles attributed by Schwab:
        Contributors who were attributed authorship to articles in the Schwab are indicated by the number 5 : e.g., Voltaire5, Saint-Lambert5, etc.

      Diderot's Articles
        Following Proust & Lough (Hermann Edition, see above) we consolidated all of the old Diderot attributions (Diderot1, Diderot2, Diderot5, etc.) into 3 categories:
          1. Article signed by Diderot (*) -- Diderot
          2. Unsigned articles which can be given clear, sure attributions and thus published in Proust’s edition -- Diderot2 
          3. Unsigned articles where possible attributions have varying degrees of certitude, and which Proust does not include in his edition -- Diderot3

      Articles by d'Alembert
        Using the list of d'Alembert articles at the end of Martine Groult's book: D'Alembert et la mécanique de la vérité dans l'Encyclopédie, we verified the list of articles that were signed with d'Alembert's mark (O) and appear as authored by d'Alembert in the database. Additionally, we added more than 50 articles that were unsigned but which can be attributed to d'Alembert with a high degree of certainty, these have d'Alembert2 as their author.
        Some articles, however, have been misrecognized (i.e. are not treated as articles, or are several subarticles, etc.) and therefore still need correcting.
          Example: Article PELÉ (actually 2 articles - PÉLÉCOÏDE missed)

      Other Contributors to the Encyclopédie
        Using the Schwab Inventory as well as Frank Kafker's The Encyclopedists as individuals we have corrected and normalized our author list. We have also added all of the known authors who signed or to whom articles were attributed.

        Currently there are 134 identified authors in our database.

    Headword Corrections
      Many Headwords have been corrected and/or expanded - Example: the "Bois" articles, etc.
      In several cases objects in articles were recognized as sub-articles, e.g., the article "BAS", where "DU FUST" was recognized as another headword.
      These have been provisionally changed to "XXX (suite)" as in "BAS (suite)" until we can make a more permanent structural change.

Metadata Corrections - Some numbers

    Old Version (12/07) New Version (11/08)
    Diderot: 5,717 articles Diderot: 6,328 articles (+611)
    D'Alembert: 1,438 articles D'Alembert: 1,634 articles (+196)
    D'Holbach: 432 articles D'Holbach: 1,049 articles (+617)
    Saint-Lambert: 0 articles Saint-Lambert: 17 articles (+17)
    No Author (XXX): 37,707 articles No Author: 35,612 (-2,095)
    Unclassified articles: 22,450 Unclassified articles: 15,833 (-6,617)
    Total Metadata Changes: 10,586
‹ Text Corrections up Greek Corrections ›

The ARTFL Project
Department of Romance Languages and Literatures
University of Chicago
1115 East 58th Street Chicago, IL 60637
tel: 773-702-8488 | email: artfl[at]artfl[dot]uchicago[dot]edu
Privacy Notice

  • Search
  • Plate Image Search
  • Front Matter
  • Introduction
  • Encyclopédistes